Best Turkey Fryers

Best Turkey Fryers

It’s almost time to start preparing for the holidays again. There’s hardly a better way to do that than by checking out the best turkey fryers now!

To be fair, good turkey fryers don’t have to be used specifically for that, either. Plenty of the newly-designed turkey fryers can fry, steam, and boil other ingredients as well!

There are quite a few things to consider before making a decision on a turkey fryer. Let’s get to know the product we’re interested in a little more!

Brand/Model Key Features Ratings More Information
Char-Broil Big Easy Holds 16lb turkey
Weighs ~30lbs
5 out of 5

For more information, click here!
Masterbuilt Butterball MB23010618 Holds 20lb turkey
Electric, indoor fryer
Weighs ~20lbs
4.8 out of 5

For more information, click here!

Turkey Fryers Aren’t Just For Thanksgiving

While most people may associate these over-sized frying pots with the task of preparing an enormous feast for numerous family members, that’s not all they’re good for.

In fact, if you enjoy gardening and/or canning, you’ll be sure to get plenty of use out of almost any of the turkey fryers you come across.

  • How much money can you expect to spend?
    • Generally, you’ll find turkey frying kits anywhere from $20 to well over $300.
    • If you already have a 10-quart pot (or larger), you can settle on turkey fryers that don’t include the piece you have. These will typically be much cheaper than any other option.
    • The more accessories there are, the more pennies you’ll probably have to spend.
  • What size and style do you need?
    • In all reality, you’ll probably need at least a 20-quart pot to fry a whole, small turkey.
    • If you’re wanting to go big or go home, you’ll want a 44-quart pot or larger, as these can generally hold turkeys that weigh more than 20 pounds.
    • Keep the number of mouths you’re feeding in mind as well as the weight of the turkey you plan to cook. Unless you want to spend all day cooking two small turkeys for a large family, you’ll need a big pot! If it’s just you, your spouse, and your kid, a smaller one should work just as well.
      • If you’re doing some serious cooking, like for a family reunion or something, some burners can hold the weight of a full 100-quart pot!
    • Your ability to lift something should also be a concern. If you have trouble lifting heavy things, you might want to opt for an aluminum model instead of a stainless steel selection.
      • Our motto is: if you can’t comfortably lift it without anything in it, you certainly won’t be able to lift it when it’s full of food.
      • Stainless steel is much easier to clean and cook with but high-grade aluminum is no joke, either. You just might not want to can your tomatoes with that pot unless the manual gives you the go-ahead.
  • Which features, components, and other miscellaneous things matter most to you?
    • A meat thermometer is one of the most important tools to have on hand when you’re cooking an entire bird or huge slab of meat.
      • You don’t want anyone getting sick from something you’ve cooked (or, rather, didn’t cook enough).
      • Turkey is definitely safe to eat if it is cooked to an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit and can maintain that temperature for at least a few minutes before being served. Some say a lower temperature is fine as well but we’re not taking any chances.
    • If you have food safety under control, then what about a strainer or a basket that will make pulling things out safer and easier for you?
      • Not only will baskets and such be a blessing in disguise, so will heavy-duty handles!
      • If you choose outdoor turkey fryers (like the kind that require propane), you’ll likely want good, sturdy handles for carrying the cooled-down unit inside for cleaning.
    • To use oil or not to use oil? That is the true question, these days!
      • Healthy is the new fabulous and many manufacturers have worked hard on offering appliances that support such a lifestyle.
      • If you still want to enjoy a deliciously crisp, yet tender, turkey without being weighed down by all the oil and grease that’s usually required for such a thing, check out the oil-less turkey fryers!
      • Oil-less fryers are better known as air fryers and often provide results that are hard to ignore. The best models do so well that you can’t even tell the meat wasn’t swimming in oil the whole time.
    • Do you need hooks, racks, and/or skewers?
      • If you’re interested in a larger option, you might be intrigued by these choices.
      • Hooks are good for cooking and pulling out ribs, boneless cuts, and more.
      • Skewers are good for kebobs or loading more than one bird in the fryer at one time.
      • Racks can be used for vegetables, thin cuts of meat, and other things.
      • Just read your unit’s specifications before you use any of its components for anything you’re uncertain of!
    • What about a lid? Do hot oil splatters scare you? (They should if they don’t)! They’re no joke! If you aren’t sure how to deal with hot oil properly, find a model with a lid to prevent unnecessary accidents and burns.
    • This is a good time to ask yourself again: what all do you need when it comes to these turkey fryers?
      • Do you need a whole kit? Have you ever cooked an entire turkey before?
      • Do you just want to free up the oven for all the other dishes you’re creating and need a separate appliance for the meat to cook properly?
      • Do you already have large pots and accessories and just need a good, sturdy burner?
      • Your needs will determine how much you’ll need to spend on turkey fryers, too!

Be Safe When Using Turkey Fryers

As we’ve already mentioned, hot oil is extremely dangerous! Oil splatters can cause small fires and explosions, depending on where they land.

We beg you to be as safe as possible when frying any food… especially whole birds!

Use gloves, protective eyewear, and the like if you need to. Who cares if you look goofy as long as you’re safe?

  • Helpful tip: 
    • Do not place a frozen or wet bird in a hot fryer!

This is asking for a catastrophe! Water and oil don’t mix, as it is. Add heat to that equation and you’re in for a serious disaster. It’s always best to make sure your bird is fully thawed and patted dry before it is placed in a fryer.

If using an outdoor turkey fryer, avoid extremely enclosed areas. Avoid extremely windy conditions, too, as this could fuel the fire a bit more than one would like.

Also, unless you’re using an air fryer, you will want to avoid seasoning the outside of the turkey until the cooking is complete! That’s why seasoning infusers and turkey basters exist.

External seasonings could react negatively with hot oil. For the best results, season the turkey’s insides in a regular fryer and use a dry rub on those that are going in an oil-less fryer.

Top Two Turkey Fryers

Char-Broil Big Easy

  • The Char-Broil Big Easy is our favorite oil-less turkey fryer.
    • It’s affordable, powerful, and aesthetically pleasing.
    • Instead of worrying about dumping in (and probably wasting) a bunch of oil each time you want to fry something up, you’ll hook up a propane tank.
    • The infrared technology helps this appliance cook meat as thoroughly and almost as quickly as a regular fryer would.
  • This is one of the lighter-weight turkey fryers, weighing in at 30 pounds before adding any ingredients.
    • Can hold a 16lb bird, making it ideal for feeding small families.
  • Comes with a mesh top to keep the ingredients from popping out.
    • Also includes a meat thermometer, a lifting tool, and a cooking basket.
    • Since it is pretty much impossible to ship things like propane in the mail (hello, it’s dangerous!), you will have to provide your own.
    • Want to cook ribs easily in this? No problem! Just order the rib hooks!
  • It is small, though it isn’t extremely lightweight, so it won’t take up a ridiculous amount of storage space.
  • Since it requires propane, we strongly suggest using this outside. Don’t risk using it inside, no matter how large your kitchen may be.
    • The manufacturer did design a cover for it if you don’t want to worry about hauling it around every time you use it.

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23010618

  • The Masterbuilt Butterball XL Electric Fryer is a beautiful, little masterpiece.
    • It can be used indoors and still uses a significantly lower amount of oil than most turkey fryers do.
    • Can easily cook a 20-pound turkey, and isn’t limited to that task. Can also handle several pounds of chicken wings or most of the ingredients for a good, ol’ crawfish boil.
    • The unit itself weighs about 20 pounds without anything in it.
  • This is one of those fancy turkey fryers, being able to fry, boil, and steam many things in a short amount of time.
    • Most turkeys can be cooked in about an hour or so, compared to several hours in standard ovens.
  • Features a basket with draining clips, two thermostat controls, a drain valve for excess oil, and more.
  • Don’t care about what it comes with and are more curious about its cleanup requirements? It breaks down easily and several components are dishwasher-safe!
    • It also has a lid, so you won’t have to worry about oil splattering all over your spotless kitchen.
  • Worried about accidents happening? Features one of those awesome breakaway cords to give you peace of mind.

In Conclusion

It depends on how big of a turkey you want to cook, what kind of features you want, and where you want to cook your turkey.

There are turkey fryers out there that can suit just about anyone’s needs if you look hard enough! There are 100-quart models (which can hold 30 pounds or more of poultry) that must have their own stations set up outside.

There are small, indoor models that make as little of a mess as possible. There are also turkey fryers that are found somewhere in the middle, being cost-efficient yet not entirely mess-free.

If you want to get the most out of your money, we recommend going with a full kit model. That way you’re able to can your own veggies and fruits if you want, host a seafood broil, or make the biggest, best pot of chili your community has ever experienced.

As always, thank you for learning about turkey fryers with us and we hope you find what you’re looking for!

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Compare items () compare